The Fairly OddParents: Fairly Odder

Cosmo and Wanda are very tired from taking care of Poof, so Timmy volunteers to take over and give them a night on the town. However, the minute they poof away, Timmy loses Poof and must find him before they return.

Timmy wishes for an indestructible luscious hairstyle so his dad does not give him any more haircuts. Meanwhile, Wanda brings Poof to the barber, Dr. Rip Studwell for a haircut, but Poof is much too resistant to the barber.

Timmy needs to go to the hospital to have his tonsils removed, because he has tonsillitis. Unfortunately, his candy striper nurse is Vicky, who is determined to make his stay in the hospital as painful as possible.

Timmy wishes to go to the Dimmsdale Pirates baseball game, but Poof accidentally wishes Timmy, Cosmo, Wanda, and himself on a real Pirate ship, and the parrot on Dirtybeard steals the stars on Cosmo and Wanda's wands.

After watching his favorite adventure/mystery TV show, "C.C. Cruiser and the Hot Rod Squad", Timmy wishes his life was exactly like the main character's, along with a female assistant and talking car. Wanda becomes his assistant and Cosmo becomes a talking, green car named Carsmo. The place that they go to seek adventure is Fairy World, where they discover that Mama Cosma is missing. However, there is a note there that reads: BRIDGE 7:00 pm. They then go to the bridge, but no one is there. Juandissimo Magnifico appears and tells them that Mama Cosma was at one of the restaurants. They go there, only to find that she is not there. Jorgen Von Strangle appears and tells Timmy and his fairies that Mama Cosma was at her house playing bridge with him, but then his teddy bear goes missing, and they must go search for it. The episode ends with all five on a freeze frame.

Feeling that Cosmo and Wanda are neglecting him for Poof, Timmy convinces his godparents to give him his own magic wand with ten wishes on it for emergencies, but he uses them unwisely.

To celebrate half day (which resulted from his parents idiotically mistaking him getting home early from school because it was only a half of a school day as an actual holiday), Timmy wishes for a machine that allows things to merge with other items to become half-human and half-object. When Crocker gets a hold of it, he accidentally merges himself with cheese, and he uses this power to capture Timmy's fairies.

When Timmy wishes for a simpler world, everyone is transported to prehistoric times, and when volcanoes hit prehistorical Dimmsdale (Dimmsrock), Timmy has to find a way to power Cosmo and Wanda's wands before the city burns down, since the town is built under four volcanoes.

When Mark Chang celebrates his one-year anniversary on Earth, they go back to Yugopatamia and Mandie marries him and became queen while Mark's dad turns into Timmy and goes to Earth. Later, Mandie becomes a dictator, so Timmy and Mark must stop her before she destroys the Earth. Also, Timmy's Dad locked Timmy up in a cage made of wood because of what Mark's dad did as Timmy.

Dark Laser tricks Timmy's parents into thinking that he is sending Timmy to a university where they will pay for his college fund. However, they do not know that the university is actually Dark Laser's ship. After approval of Timmy going to Dark Laser's university by his parents, Timmy is forced to wear a Dark Laser-type suit, which eventually takes over his mind and makes him knock out Crocker and Francis against some lockers; getting Trixie to fall in love with him; making Vicky do what he wants her to do, and other tasks. Cosmo tries to convince Timmy not to do this by telling him that fairies can make people naked. Timmy then graduates and Dark Laser forces him to blow up the earth, but Timmy deliberately decides not to. After refusing, Dark Laser does it himself, but Timmy wishes that the laser would backfire, causing the laser to destroy the spaceship. Timmy wishes he was back home, and when he gets back, he hears the explosion of the spaceship, meaning that Dark Laser survived in it. Timmy then decides to keep the suit for emergencies.

After Poof, while practicing his shape-shifting power, blows up the house, Mom and Dad find him and, thinking he is a super alien baby, want to take care of him and turn him into a super hero. Timmy now has to retrieve Poof for Cosmo and Wanda before Dad's attempts to turn Poof into a superhero get everyone into trouble.

After Timmy wears Cosmo and Wanda out, Jorgen takes Timmy to an academy to learn to be more independent and wish less along with two other children, but they attempt to escape.

Timmy wishes for a super car wash that rejuvenates everything that goes through it in order to repair for Dad's Stiker Z sports car. It works, but when dinosaurfossils and cavemen go through it, Dimmsdale is in prehistoric chaos, and when Cosmo and Wanda go through it, they turn into rebellious teens, causing Poof to disappear as they never married or had him. Fortunately, Timmy manages to convince them to become normal again, and they save him from being eaten by a dinosaur and turn everything else normal.

Timmy wishes for a super car wash that rejuvenates everything that goes through it in order to repair for Dad's Stiker Z sports car. It works, but when dinosaurfossils and cavemen go through it, Dimmsdale is in prehistoric chaos, and when Cosmo and Wanda go through it, they turn into rebellious teens, causing Poof to disappear as they never married or had him. Fortunately, Timmy manages to convince them to become normal again, and they save him from being eaten by a dinosaur and turn everything else normal.

After Vicky is arrested for erasing a videotape that the Turners were saving so then they could use it to get their own reality show, she is forced to take over Dimmsdale and wage war on Earth. Timmy must now stop her and return her to babysitting at all costs. Unfortunately, every time Timmy wishes she was not the ruler of something, she once again becomes a ruler of an extremely powerful position (Mayor of Dimmsdale, President, finally Supreme Ruler of Everything That Breathes) and destroys the world anyway. In order to stop her, Timmy must boldly wish she was his baby-sitter again.

After reading a boring issue of the Crimson Chin comics, Timmy, Cosmo, Wanda, and Poof venture into Chincinnati and realize the Chin wants a girlfriend. Timmy wishes up a match, but the Chin and Golden Locks seem to be going on dates rather than fighting crime, so when the Chin prepares to ask Goldie for their marriage, Timmy promptly wishes she went evil, but the Chin's love, now the Hair Razor, is more powerful than him, eventually leading to his surrender. Timmy must now attempt to reverse the situation, which leads to his fall down a tall building to "unlock" Golden Locks' heart from evil.

Timmy tries to find a safer job for Catman (a.k.a. Adam West) after constant injury, but each job leads to someone/something getting attacked.

When Timmy's dad, quits his job to become a sock monkey salesman (which fails horribly because no one wants to buy one because according to the episode "they don't do anything") the Turners turn their house into a bread and breakfast to avoid bankruptcy. Unfortunately, their first guests are Mr. Crocker, Dark Laser, and Tootie. Timmy cannot make any wishes, because if he does, Crocker's Magic Sensors will track the magic back to his fairies and capture them.

Timmy, who is tired of being the "guinea pig" of the Fairies, Pixies, and Anti-Fairies, wishes for a competition to see which one of them is the best magical creature. Jorgen does not let any fairy compete, however, because he is the strongest. When he wins the first five medals, Anti-Cosmo and HP knock out Jorgen. Timmy becomes the fairies' trainer and makes a bet: if Anti-Cosmo wins, Timmy will be his godchild; if HP wins, Timmy will work for him forever; and if Timmy wins, he will force HP and Anti-Cosmo to do something very bad. The fairies win, and Timmy says "nothing" for what Anti-Cosmo and HP do. Timmy says he learned that cheaters only cheat against themselves. It turns out to be a dream for Scott Hamilton (who was previously co-hosting the games with Timmy), because when he says what Timmy said, Juandissimo and Cupid give him a cheetah (a running gag involves that when anyone says cheater on the field or somewhere else other than the stands, Cupid gives them a cheetah).

After no one in Dimmsdale gets what they want for Christmas, Timmy wishes that Cosmo, Wanda and Poof could give everyone a wish in the mail. Things go wrong when greedy Vicky wishes for a million wishes causing her mailbox to explode, and everyone catches the falling wishes, thus causing the Big Wand to overload and for Jorgen to shut off the fairy's magic power. However, Jorgen actually likes Wishmas, believing Santa to be stealing fairy magic and not giving any credit, and begins promoting Wishmas. Soon, Christmas is replaced with Wishmas and unemployed Santa moves in with the Turners. Timmy now must get rid of "Jorgen the Magic Mailman," and get Christmas and Santa back.